Jump to content

Belts


cecil

Recommended Posts

  • 4 weeks later...
2 hours ago, FurnitureMaker said:

The photos look great, but I’ve never been able to see an Ace Western Belt  in real life. Does anyone have experience with them?  Positive or negative?

If you want an exact replica of an old Sears or Montgomery Ward et al then they are your guys. 

Not as good as my belts tho’ …

Edited by Duke Mantee
Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, Duke Mantee said:

 

Not as good as my belts tho’ …

Duke, you use this thread to make sales and to promote your work. Fair enough. Here is my take, basing my judgement from pictures alone (I’ve not seen your belts in person either).

I strongly disagree with you. Your bespoke craftsmanship might have an edge over the mass production approach of Ace. Maybe. Your leather options probably does the most to set you apart, most being of higher quality, I assume.

But, your belts seem sterile to me. Lacking an intangible quality that Ace has in spades. I am so curious about the Ace belts and I don’t have an interest in yours. They are over thought out and fussy. Lacking spontaneity. 

And I haven’t gotten to the second main component of a belt. The buckles. Ace gets their own buckles made to their specs. Hard to compete with that. 

It triggers me to see someone with an obvious conflict of interest put themselves above another maker. If your claim is true, and it might well be, (certainly the opinion of almost everyone on this forum), isn’t it better to have them make the claim so you don’t have to?

All right, I’ve got that off my chest.  If I haven’t completely offended you and you are willing to humor me this bit of advice I’ll end it with this. I encourage you to make a small line of belts that put your talent on full display while showing your personal style. Along with your custom work, it would be cool to see a few signature pieces. 
 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, FurnitureMaker said:

Duke, you use this thread to make sales and to promote your work. Fair enough. Here is my take, basing my judgement from pictures alone (I’ve not seen your belts in person either).

I strongly disagree with you. Your bespoke craftsmanship might have an edge over the mass production approach of Ace. Maybe. Your leather options probably does the most to set you apart, most being of higher quality, I assume.

But, your belts seem sterile to me. Lacking an intangible quality that Ace has in spades. I am so curious about the Ace belts and I don’t have an interest in yours. They are over thought out and fussy. Lacking spontaneity. 

And I haven’t gotten to the second main component of a belt. The buckles. Ace gets their own buckles made to their specs. Hard to compete with that. 

It triggers me to see someone with an obvious conflict of interest put themselves above another maker. If your claim is true, and it might well be, (certainly the opinion of almost everyone on this forum), isn’t it better to have them make the claim so you don’t have to?

All right, I’ve got that off my chest.  If I haven’t completely offended you and you are willing to humor me this bit of advice I’ll end it with this. I encourage you to make a small line of belts that put your talent on full display while showing your personal style. Along with your custom work, it would be cool to see a few signature pieces. 
 

 

I was making a joke … but if you feel better after your broadside then I’ve succeeded even though you didn’t see the humour.

FWIW I would never claim anything I make is better than anything by anyone else, it would be arrogant and most probably false … and on a few occasions I’ve used those beautiful ACE buckles you mention (gotten to know them reasonably well too).

I appreciate your advice on what I should do with my ‘business’ (such as it is) but I’m happy enough making what any interested party asks me to make - won’t be too many more now anyway.

Edited by Duke Mantee
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 and half years ago after a fair bit of chat and a lot of encouragement from my mate @Flash I started making belts with some purpose.

The purpose was that I had retired to look after my little girl who has multiple disabilities and in intervening hours I wanted to do something to slow down brain atrophy coupled with the fact that I’d bought a Warehouse belt which transpired to be shit.

Since then, and much to my very genuine surprise, I’ve now made a little over 200 belts … slightly better than 1 belt every week. That’s the extent of my ‘business’.

Each belt is made to the requirements and specifications set out by the customer. Each belt is made entirely by hand - no electrically or manually operated machines whatsoever. Skiving, edge bevelling, burnishing and the like are done according to how I ‘read’ each piece of leather being used. I have never made the same belt twice - some are similar, but respectfully that’s down to the request and invariably there will still be fundamental differences.

Because every belt is different, there is no easy way (or wish) to standardise the process or materials. This also means I cannot easily plan ahead or take advantage of cost savings in ‘bulk’ purchasing.

In terms of the money I ‘make’ from this enterprise - I charge exactly what I pay for any materials and add the honest number hours labour (at UK minimum wage).

If I take a picture of a belt - I’ll normally display it here, and post it on IG (if the owner allows). I guess that can be considered as advertising but I don’t look for new opportunities or sales. If I’m asked, I’m asked, if I’m not then it makes no difference - I’ve just explained that it’s not a source of income that makes any substantive impact on household income, even if it was predictable.

Because Standard Rivet has closed down I can no longer replenish my studs/spots, so my ‘business’ will soon close down … that should be good news to Miho at ACE

But anyway, thank you to everyone who has trusted me with their hard earned, I hope I’ve never let you down.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

@Duke Mantee I’m not sure if you take the same pleasure or interest in making other leather goods, but I am quite happy to own two different bags you’ve made as well, and look forward to using them for some long time or even passing down an old weathered version of one if they make it. And the one simple belt is far and away the nicest one I’ve ever owned, and one that I’m proud to wear when the occasion calls for it. 

Understanding it is not exactly a profitable enterprise for you I very much appreciate the task you’ve set out for yourself, as my son went through a pretty rough journey some years ago that made me have to really revisit my priorities and responsibilities in life. It’s a different situation of course, but it makes the things I’ve gotten from you that little bit much more important. I hope you’ll keep working with leather even if Standard is closed, but if not, I am grateful for having gotten the chance to own some of the thoughtfully made pieces you’ve spent your time on. 

Edited by ATWM
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Double 0 Soul said:

So there is only one place in the world where you can buy your hardwear?

How come? .. where will other leather workers get theirs?

Standard Rivet were ‘the’ suppliers - almost right back to the earliest days. There’s another company, SX Industries, who make similar … similar isn’t the same (sizes and specs), plus they’re not geared to tiny business - pretty big minimum orders on stuff you need, but don’t need much of; for example I could buy 1000 spots which would do maybe 4 or 5 belts, but the ring spots (for jewels) are also 1000 min which is closer to 100 belts 🤷‍♂️

Edited by Duke Mantee
Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, ATWM said:

@Duke Mantee I’m not sure if you take the same pleasure or interest in making other leather goods, but I am quite happy to own two different bags you’ve made as well, and look forward to using them for some long time or even passing down an old weathered version of one if they make it. And the one simple belt is far and away the nicest one I’ve ever owned, and one that I’m proud to wear when the occasion calls for it. 

Understanding it is not exactly a profitable enterprise for you I very much appreciate the task you’ve set out for yourself, as my son went through a pretty rough journey some years ago that made me have to really revisit my priorities and responsibilities in life. It’s a different situation of course, but it makes the things I’ve gotten from you that little bit much more important. I hope you’ll keep working with leather even if Standard is closed, but if not, I am grateful for having gotten the chance to own some of the thoughtfully made pieces you’ve spent your time on. 

Thank you very very much for that

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Duke Mantee said:

Standard Rivet were ‘the’ suppliers - almost right back to the earliest days. There’s another company, SX Industries, who make similar … similar isn’t the same (sizes and specs), plus they’re not geared to tiny business - pretty big minimum orders on stuff you need,but don’t need much of; for example I could buy 1000 spots which would do maybe 4 or 5 belts, but the ring spots (for jewels) are also 1000 min which is closer to 100 belts 🤷‍♂️

Have you spoken to them.. re- a custom order, ie- less units /item but large enough order value to be worthwhile?

.. or maybe a co-op with other leather workers.. surely everyone will feel the pinch and be looking for alternatives.

Do Standard Rivet manufacture the spots or just order them in and sell them on?

Edited by Double 0 Soul
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, Double 0 Soul said:

Have you spoken to them.. re- a custom order, ie- less units /item but large enough order value to be worthwhile?

.. or maybe a co-op with other leather workers.. surely everyone will feel the pinch and be looking for alternatives.

Yep - and no

But I can’t be arsed pursuing other ‘options’ - as I said, it was never about money. I’ll pass my time with wallets and bags. I enjoy spending the time; it’s a different type of project and the bigger items can take a week or more so you really get your teeth into it 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

×
×
  • Create New...