yes or no? / this or that?

[RBales]

^^ it's a shawl you can fold the collar down.

definitely the first. that color is awesome.

[lmaozedong]

second for sure. ervell winter alpaca knits so much better than summer cotton shit

[bluespring]

i say neither, just get the fair isle sweater

[american_hearts]

i say neither, just get the fair isle sweater

True talk. The fair isle in cream/navy is perfect. I don't see the appeal of a sweater with a chest pocket at all.

[Guest White Man's Burden]

or

Keep in mind I got moc toes for days... I really wanna get some round-toe shoes thrown in the mix but those oakwoods are callin me.

[jwsach]

bottom ones look better in about every way

[Guest White Man's Burden]

even if your go-to is a pair of these?

[american_hearts]

I'd go with the redwings myself but, hey -- if you're stocked up on moccs, there's probably a reason for it. Stick with variations on your style. Sometimes there's no reason to switch.

[Guest White Man's Burden]

I'd go with the redwings myself but, hey -- if you're stocked up on moccs, there's probably a reason for it. Stick with variations on your style. Sometimes there's no reason to switch.

You just contradicted yourself like 8 times in 30 words.

[capa]

I'm not sold on this color.

[home]

^ are they vanishing elephant? quality is not there.

[lmaozedong]

yeah ive had a couple pairs of vanishing elephants. would rather save up and buy comeys

[Guest White Man's Burden]

Aright I'm revising this one a bit....

or

The J Crew boots don't look as burnished in person, btw..

[Guest I LOVE LFC]

Personally I'd say the first pair, because I've tried them on and was going to get them my self. I'm not in to the second pair as they look like work boots, which I have to wear every day anyway, but maybe thats your thing.

Although I like The Oak Streets better from before. (Hopefully) 5 weeks 'til mine arrive!

[Gecko]

RW chukkas are lovely, my tan pair have been worn to death and still looking good.

[gonegonegone]

trying to find a nice pair of boots for the winter.

i've come across these:

those are almost 400 bucks though, yes or no?

[Fycus]

I love those boots, but I don't know if I could justify a purchase of what looks like a rubber sole. If it was stacked leather I would be more inclined to purchase. However, you can always resole?

[pepper davies]

Quoddy Ring Boot

or

Wolverine Addison

I'm starting to think the answer is both...

[Egpt]

The first ones are atrocious, the second ones are just horrible (because of the color).

[Guest White Man's Burden]

I like Quoddy's ring boot a lot, but you need crepe soles otherwise you'll look like a Shaman (and not in a good way).

[Vampyrvargfesten]

so many ugly brown shoes on the previous page

don't buy any of them

[american_hearts]

You just contradicted yourself like 8 times in 30 words.

What? Okay, Cliff's notes:

If it were me, I'd get the RW because it fits my style.

but

I recommend you get the Oak Street because it sounds like it fits your style.

[jackg]

y/n??

[aoi]

My immediate response was supposed to be YES! But I'm not so sure I like the silhouette. Toe reminds me of those racing shoes from a few years back.

If you feel it goes well with your wardrobe, go for it. But I think there are nicer BWs out there.

[huckleberry8]

http://www.thorocraftshop.com/mm5/graphics/00000001/TC0015B_01.jpg

Haven't heard anything about thorocraft but I like the look of these, anyone know how the quality is?

[frankie_four]

The sole looks like Opening Ceremonie's and I thought I read they are made in Portugal, too.

[baisemoi]

http://www.coutie.com/de/duke-leather-white-p-5711.html

or

http://www.coutie.com/de/iggy-greywhite-p-4955.html

both to be worn with skinny jeans

I'm a little bit scared that the duke could look too chunky on my feet, the iggy isn't all white though..

[huckleberry8]

Portugal isn't necessarily a bad thing, I agree with you about the sole though and I know Opening Ceremony have notoriously bad issues within that area.

[Rampancy]

Black Scissors RO knock-off, made to my measurements. $350

or, for double the price

The only issue on it is that the sleeves are measured at 48 cm. Can anyone with experience with this jacket/brand tell me if they fit longer somehow?

Edit: Just realized I'm also gonna need a sweater or two and possibly a heavier jacket as well....hmmm...

[drapygo]

or