@cultpop 0217, I have some Barker brogues - the Nunthorpe in rosewood (bought in 2014), which look similar to yours but without the skulls, etc. I had to send them back and exchange them for a half size down from my standard shoe size as they do come up big. They may be built on a similar last to yours. I know you can’t exchange your Archdales but just thought I’d let you know that it’s not you, it’s the shoes (although they’re still very nice)!