I'm a 17.5 – now that you mention it, I do see 18 popping up every so often, but I nabbed this one BNWT for around US $70 a few years back. Babying it has worked so far, just have to make sure Mrs Mondo doesn't inadvertently add it to an inappropriate load at the weekend – I usually look after that side of things on weekdays. I find FW shirt sizing variable according to cut (duh) and fabric – I've an outlaw in micro HBT that is verging on sausage-casing territory and a paraffin cloth army shirt that swims on me (works fine as an overshirt).. the Neal and another wabash shirt are both just right.
When I get sizes wrong I usually sneak the offending item into my 18 y.o. son's wardrobe as he's 6'3" with classic clotheshorse proportions.. it's nice to see some of this stuff being worn without any reason beyond it being a well-made functional garment that doesn't shoehorn the wearer into some subculture or other. I gave a pair of FW51 a hot wash and the patch turned to shrunken jerky – his poor Dad couldn't cope with the pain, but he gave zero shits and now they're worn as they should be. I, uh, did have a second pair waiting in the wings in a better size and chainstitched to the ideal length for me, though. This is sufu, after all..