Late on this but I ended up getting proper shoes in the form of Crockett & Jones Cavendish tassel loafers and some less dressy Crockett & Jones Cornell's. The Cavendish were 50% off during the Todd Snyder sale. And the Cornell's were in C&Js winter sale this year. I would not pay the US retail price for these shoes. IMO Allen Edmonds shoes are really lackluster in real life. The leather is lifeless, dull and the make of the shoe was honestly not great. Sure MiUSA but Grant Stone by comparison absolutely shits all over them.
If you can find some used Grant Stone, C&J, Trickers, whoever else making good shoes on eBay I think that would be a good bet. But obviously that's risky from a size perspective. I wouldn't bother buying new at $200 unless its a good sale. You're too limited to shit department store shoes at $200 retail price.